
Online or off, the fundamentals don't
change
| Brett N. Silvers |
August 2000 |
Chairman and Chief Executive Officer,
First International Bank,
a subsidiary of First International Bancorp, Inc.
Railroads are among the many industries joining the
Internet-sparked business-to-business (B2B) electronic revolution. Currently,
railroad buyers, suppliers, and contractors can take advantage of electronic
transmission of bids, purchase orders, blueprints, and documents, as well as
auction sites and bulletin boards. They can even obtain financing online.
Just as railroads helped bring about the industrial
revolution, the Internet is revolutionizing commerce once again. The growth is
staggering. In 1999, B2B e-commerce totaled $130 billion in transactions
worldwide. The Gartner Group projects that global commerce conducted in
e-business marketplaces will surpass $7.3 trillion by 2004. What will drive
business people to log on and take part? From the media attention generated by
e-business, one might conclude that it's a passing craze, unlikely to meet a
fraction of present expectations.
If companies are expected to conduct business online
successfully, they must mimic the tactics learned by doing business off-line.
Access to financing is fundamental to both ends of the sales transaction.
Sellers need credit to produce the goods; buyers, to purchase them. If 17% of
U.S. sales take place on the Internet over the next four years, as has been
predicted, many of these sales will require financing, particularly for small
and medium size industrial companies.
Today there are approximately 700 e-business marketplaces
where companies can meet, negotiate, buy, and sell online, with the number
expected to grow to 1,000 by the end of this year.
One breed of e-commerce marketplace that can offer commercial
financing and other advantages for industry is the "neutral"
marketplace. This model is operated by independent dot-com portals that link up
buyers and sellers within a specific industry (a "vertical
community").
Neutral marketplaces are keenly aware that financing, as a
form of content, is key to attracting buyers and sellers to transact business on
their sites. Financial partners offer marketplaces a powerful tool for boosting
site traffic and attracting loyal members. The credit provider, however, needs
to observe e-business basics:
• A site should have all the essential financial products
"on the shelf" for enabling e-commerce: basic working capital lines,
equipment loans and industrial mortgages, and sophisticated international trade,
barter, and energy financing programs.
• Most small and medium size companies that apply for
commercial credit have a "story" to tell.
Credit may be used to power a new initiative, take a stand
against competitive pressures, end a sales slump, or upgrade energy systems.
Good credit providers understand these stories and incorporate them into lending
decisions.
• Online lenders must be able to underwrite loans no matter
where in the world an applicant is located, how complicated the loan request, or
how interesting their story. Assessing an applicant's creditworthiness is a
challenge on the Internet. It's a global network with invisible borders between
nations and economies.
• No matter how fast information flows, an underwriter
still needs time to interpret the accounting and financial standards that apply
to each transaction. Every country has its own requirements. Shared global
standards for many basic commercial procedures do not exist. For example, in
many jurisdictions, people still need to sign on the dotted line with ink to
secure an agreement. Electronic signatures generally remain unenforceable
(although the U.S. Congress took a big step forward in June 2000 when
legislation was passed validating e-signatures).
• Concern for security deters companies from disclosing
financial information online. To be successful, online financing partners should
offer logical product screens and easy-to-use applications, where credit data
can be securely transmitted.
The current reality is, without a stamp, most small and
medium size companies applying for credit have no way to submit corporate
financial information online. Many business documents are not yet
Internet-friendly. Two forms of online credit have emerged to support small and
medium size companies doing e-commerce. One is an "instant"
credit-card type of transaction that uses personal financial data from business
owners to credit-score loans up to $100,000. Another approach, which more truly
mirrors classic commercial and international lending, bases credit decisions on
a corporation's financial information, and permits loans up to $5 million.
Instant online financing for million-dollar B2B transactions
is still to come. I would argue that the skeptics have it all wrong. Financial
innovators break new ground every day, bringing the business world closer to
routine Internet-based deals-at the click of a mouse. n