
The ABCs Of E-Business
E-transformation is
forcing IT and business managers to relearn their roles
| By Diane Rezendes Khirallah |
March 20, 2000
|
Six months ago, if First International Bank CEO Brett
Silvers spoke once a month to his VP of IT, John Garner, that was a lot. Now,
with the bank in the throes of an E-transformation effort, the two speak
daily. In recent months, each has learned more about the other's work than
they ever expected to before the E-business undertaking began. And that
cross-pollination doesn't stop at the top: One-on-one collaboration between
business and IT managers takes place at every level of the bank.
"We've become much more collaborative," Silvers
says. "We never had tech people so involved in the guts of the
organization. The more our technology people are trained on sales and credit,
the faster they can translate and integrate what we do into E-business."
As companies pursue new ways of doing business, an
increasing number of business and IT managers are finding it necessary to
learn more about their counterparts' areas of expertise. In training centers
and on corporate campuses nationwide, business professionals are learning
about new Internet technologies, and IT managers are studying the finer points
of sales, marketing, and finance.
Some go it alone, reading, studying, and surfing the
Web to expand their sphere of knowledge. Others carve time out of their
too-busy schedules to attend intensive one-day or one-week courses offered by
universities or other organizations (for example, InformationWeek's
five-day Executive Boot Camp, being held this week in Berkeley, Calif.). Some
even go back to school, juggling a combination of on-campus and online
learning while maintaining a significant profile within their companies.
Whatever the method, the increased collaboration between IT and business has
caused a blurring of the lines that demands an open mind interested in
learning.
The new cross-training programs go far beyond well-meaning
efforts to foster career development in professionals. A growing number of
executives and educators are citing knowledge-sharing between business and IT
professionals as a requirement for companies to achieve customer satisfaction,
efficient operations, and a competitive advantage in today's fast-paced,
technology-powered new economy.
"Marketing and business are constantly asking what's
possible. IT needs to know what's desired," says Robert Reich, former
U.S. Secretary of Labor and a professor at Brandeis University in Waltham,
Mass. For that reason, the traditional, hierarchical business model no longer
works, and the new economy calls for companies that foster collaboration via a
more horizontal structure. Marketing and IT have to continually share
information with each other "so they can have a continual stream of
information going to their customers," Reich says.
Yet only 20% of U.S. companies have begun to create
customer-driven teams that bring these departments together, Reich says. But
as more companies begin to realize the importance of shared knowledge, they're
emphasizing collaboration between the once-disparate departments of business
and IT and forcing changes in the very structure of the business.
At Schneider National Inc., the nation's largest long-haul
freight carrier, business analysts are learning how to manipulate a
multidimensional database so they can analyze their own data rather than wait
for the IT department to serve up results. They receive the most in-depth IT
training of any nontechnical professionals in the company--as much as 10 days
at a business-intelligence training center at Schneider's headquarters in
Green Bay, Wis. "We spent a lot of energy making sure it was taught in
business language, not IT language," says Bill Braddy, director of
knowledge services at Schneider.
Meanwhile, IT managers shadow customer-service
representatives on the job--even donning headphones to listen in on customer
calls--to gain insight into how reps use IT on the front lines of the
business. "It's a necessary and advisable part of getting comfortable
with the business," says Braddy, who participated in the customer-service
insight training when he joined Schneider. "It was a humbling
experience."
The experience taught Braddy that the service rep must have
quick access to a wealth of information about each customer, including
personalized data, geographic location, and the level of importance of meeting
delivery dates. Equally important--and not to be found in any manual--the
training experience gives IT professionals a chance to observe the
relationship between customers and service reps. "When you listen to the
conversations and watch them interact, you can see what they need to know
about the customer and gain first-hand knowledge about how those information
services are used," Braddy says. "It's much more powerful than what
you get out of a procedures guide."
But the best interaction at Schneider, Braddy says, is an
intense, early-morning weekly meeting of a nine-member committee that
represents all major units of the company. The purpose: to audition the ideas
of business managers proposing IT-driven projects.
In preparation, business managers perform research across
just about every department in the company. They must explain the reason for a
project, its methodology and time line, and the expected return on investment.
"The audience has a pretty good idea of what works and what
doesn't," Braddy says. "They'll be listening very carefully to see
what's feasible. They ask tough questions."
Fortunately, IT collaboration helps preserve the
credibility of any E-business idea that business managers float: Each
presenter is flanked by an IT sponsor who can assist with technical questions
from the committee.
The new era of collaboration often starts at the CEO level.
At First International, in Hartford, Conn., Silvers knew that for a successful
E-business implementation, close collaboration with Garner was essential. In
the process, he had to change his way of thinking about IT. "As CEO, I'm
the one most inclined to believe that technology is this imponderable black
box and that technology solutions are expensive and very time-consuming to
develop," he says.
Silvers searched for companies well into their global
Internet business-to-business efforts, concentrating on the industrial
marketplace--chemicals, steel, and plastic. He and Garner set up meetings with
IT, business, and sales executive teams from 10 companies, hoping to gain a
sense of direction for their own efforts. Why the industrial market? Silvers
knew such companies might be interested in the bank as a strategic partner for
their commercial customers who require financing.
The breakthrough for First International's
business-to-business implementation came within 48 hours of one of the first
of these meetings. "John [Garner] had the whole process delineated,
illustrated, and ready to go at very little cost," Silvers says.
"The entire process was mirrored out for how information would need to
flow. I was surprised."
During the course of their collaboration, Silvers has
learned a great deal about IT, and Garner, who had never been involved in the
business of the bank, has become conversant in acquisitions, loan processing,
disbursement, and servicing.
Throughout First International, the pace of change and the
newness of a technology-driven marketplace is providing excellent learning
opportunities, Silvers says. As the company moves toward E-business, workers
across every department are learning together, hashing out what their
E-business model will be.
"We have technical people sitting in a room [with
salespeople] theorizing all the way through implementation," he says.
"That never used to happen. And because technical people are involved,
our sales staff is becoming more technology-savvy. We're starting to see them
develop leadership with their own staff along the way."
Meetings are only the starting point; after they've wrapped
up, the sales staff is expected to implement the strategy, involving yet more
cross-discipline collaboration. In addition, "The head of IT is now
called on for soup-to-nuts conceptualizing--leading people, cajoling them, and
training them," says Silvers. "It's made our IT people better
managers, too."
There will be formal training as well. Silvers plans to
send all of First International's executive managers, including those from IT,
to Yale's Management School for executive education, which he describes as
"very heavy into organizational behavior, working in teams, and
leadership." This year, IT staffers will attend sessions on the core
business--banking, financial accounting, and statements, for example. Outside
trainers who worked with the sales staff will offer sales training to IT
staff.
Meanwhile, colleges and universities are pushing hard to
meet rapidly growing demand for cross-training. For example, Stanford
University's graduate school of business in Stanford, Calif., will launch a
three-day E-commerce program in September (it's already oversubscribed); and
Bentley College is building a multimillion-dollar E-commerce education
facility set to open in July on its Waltham, Mass., campus.
Executives and managers should be completely open to
continual learning and ready to absorb new information as fast as they can,
says Bill Miller, former board chairman of Borland International Inc.,
professor emeritus, and one of the co-founders of the executive education
program at Stanford. The one- and two-week programs hosted by the university,
at a cost of $6,300 and $11,500, respectively, bring in as many as 50
executives from companies around the world. Usually the group includes five
CEOs and five CIOs, with the balance consisting of direct reports, such as VPs
and business-unit mangers. In addition to learning from one another, they also
come to glean insights from Silicon Valley notables who serve as guest
lecturers.
Several courses fall under an area the university calls
Strategic Uses of Information Technology. All involve theory, analysis, and
business case studies done in teams. "There's a triangle that includes
technology, strategy, and organization," says professor Haim Mendelson,
who directs the program with Miller. "We provide instructors from each of
these areas to offer perspectives on each of these concepts." It's
important to give students the ability to put the concepts into practice,
Mendelson says. "Actionable information is what's most important. We make
sure we show people how to use that."
According to Miller, the courses' greatest benefit stems
not from content, but from an attitudinal shift. "The combination of
analytical work, plus the cases, helps them orient their mindset," Miller
says. For example, business managers "won't be great technical experts
after two weeks, but this gives them a strong framework."
Collaboration with universities can come in a number of
ways. Steve Finnerty, CIO of Kraft Foods Inc., recalls a cross-training effort
that began with a book assignment and led to a program with Northwestern
University's business school. In mid-1999, 10 to 15 top IT managers, including
Finnerty, who was chief technology officer at the time, and Jim Kinney, who
retired as CIO in March, met for a three-day strategy session, using Unleashing
The Killer App (Harvard Business School Press, 1998), by Larry Downes and
Chunka Mui, as a springboard for discussion.
To draw in business leaders, Kraft's executive committee,
led by CEO Robert Eckert, then brought in Northwestern University business
professor Anthony Paoni to lead a two-hour discussion of E-business
strategies. That led Kraft to hire Northwestern to create a two-day E-commerce
program in July for about 50 of its executives, including Finnerty and other
top IT managers. "We had people surfing the Net together, conducting
brainstorming sessions," Finnerty says. Managers who before thought of
E-business only in terms of reaching consumers online to sell products now
understand other strategies, such as business-to-business marketplaces.
Finnerty, who has an MBA, says the most important
cross-training still goes on outside classrooms. Midcareer IT managers can
take part in leadership programs that pair them with more senior mentors on
the business side, such as finance or marketing, to provide them with
real-life understanding of business issues. "Training programs only
provide 10% of the growth; 90% comes from experience," Finnerty says.
In their haste to get managers up to speed, some companies
are pushing universities to do more. Case in point: PricewaterhouseCoopers'
strategy for putting 10,000 partners through a three-day, custom E-business
strategy program. Rather than dictate a specific curriculum,
PricewaterhouseCoopers went to six top business schools and asked them each to
build a program focused on the characteristics an E-business executive needs,
such as understanding how the Internet has increased the rate of change in
business. "We want to make sure they get the message: E-business is
different," says Chris Kinsey, a consultant in global E-business
leadership who worked on the education program.
Last May, PricewaterhouseCoopers pushed the University of
Virginia's Darden Business School to create the first course in two months,
instead of a traditional six-month cycle for a new executive education course.
The firm also insists that the schools--Carnegie Mellon, UCLA, University of
Virginia, Instead in France, and the business schools of London and Melbourne,
Australia--update the program after each session and share their courses with
one another. In return, the schools get a steady flow of paying consultants
and PricewaterhouseCoopers clients to the on-campus program, and the firm lets
the schools sell the custom course to people unrelated to
PricewaterhouseCoopers.
Traditionally, business and IT people have been on opposite
sides of the room, says David Hernandez, executive creative director of
consulting firm Quantum Leap Communications Inc. Hernandez is working with
American Airlines Inc. to redesign its Web site using technology from
BroadVision Inc. that provides customers visiting the site with personalized
content. "Even to have credibility in a conversation with the IT
department, you have to have a base level knowledge of what the IT people are
using--so they can at least push back."
Sales and marketing executives at American Airlines are
taking training with BroadVision products to keep up with the technology
capabilities of their Web site, which services 32 million frequent fliers and
occasional visitors. "They need to understand and manage the business
rules involved in BroadVision," says John Samuels, VP of interactive
marketing at the airline. "Once they can apply the business rules to the
frequent-flier data in their Sabre reservation system and AAdvantage DB2
database, they can create personalized travel promotions." IT staff from
US Web/CKS, which handles the technical side of the site, gets some training
on the inner workings of the airline's business.
Not every executive views cross-training as a necessity in
the move to E-business. Irving Miller, who was appointed VP for office of the
Web at Toyota Motor Sales USA Inc. earlier this year, isn't sold on the idea.
"I don't know if you need to do crossover training or not," says
Miller, who comes from a business marketing background. His own approach to
learning about IT involved "hours and hours and hours of surfing,"
and keeping up with IT publications. Of the businesspeople he's brought into
his seven-month-old division, he says, "It's not a formal training that's
required as much as a 'no-fear' attitude."
One of the biggest challenges of knowledge sharing is the
language gap between business and IT. Surprisingly, the gap can be
particularly wide at the CIO-CEO level, according to Northwestern's Paoni.
CEOs tend to talk in broad strategic terms, while CIOs focus on implementation
and turn to technical language. It's the difference between why do it and how
to do it. "I've seen CEOs ask strategic questions and watch the CIO jump
right into the how," Paoni says.
An environment imbued with change is a call to action. CIOs
should be in line to become the next generation of CEOs, but executives from
other areas--marketing, operations, and finance--are taking Northwestern's
E-commerce executive education classes in greater numbers than IT executives.
That's surprising--and it should be a wake-up call for IT professionals.
"You can't get from the old economy to the new economy without a good
CIO," Paoni says. "What a great time to be a CIO, if you're willing
to learn." n