|

Want Easy Money?
Look for lenders who say yes.
Raising Capital
| By Juan Hovey |
November, 2000 |
Founders of startups and fast growing businesses hate the
fundraising mating dance. Just ask Leticia and Tony Bucio, who are a little worn
out from this laborious exercise. Despite the fact that their four-year-old auto
body repair shop, Top Finish Collision Center, in Santa Ana, Calif., was
thriving, they say their bank, Banco Popular, dithered with their loan
application for more than a year. Disgusted, in April the duo called on CIT
Group, a huge commercial finance company. In two
weeks CIT had approved an $820,000 loan secured by the company's equipment and
real estate at a low rate.
"With the bank, if it wasn't one thing it was
another," Leticia Bucio says, noting that her $556,000 company posted
revenue and earnings growth of 100% and 25%, respectively, in 1999. "In
September of last year they wanted to put us on hold until after we had filed
our taxes. I said, You know what? If you guys can't see the big picture, you're
out of here."
The Bucios' experience illustrates an important trend in the
world of small business lending. Banks have plenty of competition from other
purveyors of debt finance on Main Street. Increasingly, commercial finance
companies are doling out cash to small business owners who have been spurned by
banks for having short track records, spotty credit histories, or prickly income
statements where black ink ebbs and flows due to sporadic bursts of growth.
That's because these firms use a slightly different approach to assess a
business owner's creditworthiness. Their focus is the quality of a borrower's
assets such as inventory and receivables-and the person's future ability to pay
off debts.
It's no wonder, then, that the entrepreneurial boom has
ignited a surge in the commercial lending field. Today there are nearly 300 such
financiers, specializing in various niches. The lenders range in size from
credit boutiques such as Reservoir Capital Corp., a commercial finance company
in Baltimore that lends primarily to high-tech businesses, to First Capital
Corp. in Oklahoma City, which lends to manufacturers and distributors, to the
large chains such as CIT that offer a variety of products, from equipment
finance to real estate loans. The grand total of asset-based loans outstanding
in 1999: $293 billion, according to the Commercial Finance Association
in New York City.
Even many banks, attracted by the upside potential of
asset-based lending, are muscling in on the action. One is First International
in Hartford (1999 assets: $328 million), which may give up its state charter and
reconstitute itself as a commercial finance company. In 1999 the institution
sold the last of its branches in order to concentrate on asset-based lending in
its niche market-small and mid-sized family-owned manufacturers, wholesalers,
and distributors-from its 15 offices in the U.S. and 14 overseas.
"Beginning with my tenure 13 years ago," says CEO Brett Silvers,
"we began to deemphasize the classic bank stuff -- checking and savings
accounts -- and focus on making asset-based loans. It's more profitable."
What does an asset-based loan cost? The expense depends on
the quality of the assets securing the loan and on the paperwork involved in
tracking it. But the good new is, competition has driven down rates by as much
as two percentage points. The Bucios pay slightly more than one point above
prime for their loan. Typically a business owner will pay more than the Bucios
did sometimes a lot more to borrow against inventory or receivables because of
the work involved in monitoring the value of the assets. Interest rates on loans
against receivables, for example, range from two to eight or more points above
prime (it was 9.5% at press time), depending on the quality of the risk, says
John Fox, president of Reservoir Capital. For a startup with no record of
profitability or a firm recovering from a financial setback such as an
unexpected loss, rates could be as high as 25%. But for a fast-growing business
with solid net worth and Fortune 1000 clients, it would be on the low end. In
addition, commercial finance companies often charge commitment fees of up to
1.5% and a monthly servicing charge that can range from .025% to 1%.
How do asset-based lenders justify the high costs?
"Bankers won't typically touch these risks," says Fox. "You can
justify the price of these loans by the fact that they are often life preservers
for those ready to sink."
Steven Melick and Erik Carrozza are CEO and CFO,
respectively, of the Sycamore Group, an e-business software developer in Fort
Washington, Pa., that had $3.5 million in revenues last year. They pay interest
that fluctuates between 12% and 15% for a $1.25 million working-capital loan
from GE Capital (like CIT, a mammoth U.S. commercial finance company with 1999
revenues of $4.44 billion) that's secured by their receivables. Founded in 1996,
the Sycamore Group sees revenues grow by 300% annually, Carrozza says. The
company quickly outstripped the ability of its first lender, a local bank, to
finance receivables. "We started out with a $25,000 line of credit,"
Carrozza says. "In 18 months we scaled that up to $250,000, and we had to
reapply five times. At that point we started looking around for another source
because it was taking too much of my time to futz around with the bank."
To sweeten the pie, Melick and Carrozza say, GE Capital
agreed to expand their line of credit to $1.5 million by the end of this year
and to at least $2 million in 2001 to pace their growth. In addition, GE Capital
advances against 85% of their software receivables, enabling the firm to borrow,
for example, $85,000 on $100,000 in receivables-a high rate reflecting the fact
that the firm has a prestigious list of customers. Banks and most other
commercial finance companies, in contrast, commonly advance against no more than
75% of receivables and 50% of inventory.
To shop for the right asset-based lender, follow a simple
idea: Find one that understands your industry niche. Better yet, find two or
three and let them compete for your business. Check out the Website of the
Commercial Finance Association ( www.cfa.com),
where members list the types of loans they make. Ask your peers in the business
community, too. And ask the bank on the corner-you can be sure it knows the
competition. Last but not least, check with your professional advisers, and
don't close a deal without their help.n
|