Turning inventory has always been the key to
the metal distribution game. After all, unsold 50,000-pound coils of steel can
really clutter up a balance sheet, let alone a warehouse. Still in search of
profits, today's hottest metals exchanges offer a lot more than the opportunity
to buy and sell excess prime-grade steel. Some give access to prequalified
suppliers whose inventory runs the gamut from tool steel to titanium. Others
provide technical material specs and Web site design. Still more exchanges are
railing out financing and shipping functions-even the chance to reserve time on
a mill. (If they don't provide these services, forthcoming consortia of big
industry players may turn them to slag.) We're not suggesting that you scrap the
occasional tee time with customers, but 50 to 500 basis points for each
transaction-and perhaps a small yearly subscription to a given site-is probably
worth it to move those pesky coils.
E-Steel
(Private)
www.esteel.com
CHIEF EXECUTIVE: Michael Levin
MODEL: Marketplace
DESCRIPTION: Michael Levin's second attempt at a steel exchange. Users
post material, send inquiries and haggle in private chat rooms. Cost: between 30
and 88 basis points per transaction. Plans to charge a monthly subscription fee
and referral fees for financing and logistics services.
CLIENTS: 2,300 metal suppliers, including Ford Motor and USX Corp.
BUZZ: Working with First International Bank to automate credit delivery.
Ford agreed to buy 4 million tons of steel products here.
MaterialNet.com
(Private)
www.materialnet.com
CHIEF EXECUTIVE: David Centner
MODEL: Marketplace
DESCRIPTION: Youngest of metals' big three (including E-Steel and
Metalsite), the company runs reverse auctions between buyers and brokers of coin
-I semifinished products and raw materials. Example: A manufacturer enters a
request for a quote and service centers bid against each other to win the order.
Sellers pay a 1.5% to 5% transaction fee, based on volume. Materials include
stainless steel, nickel and titanium.
CLIENTS: More than 400 metals suppliers.
BUZZ: Introduced its "Beat This Price" auction format, in which
buyers set the opening price and commit to the purchase upfront.
MetalSite
(Private)
www.metalsite.com
CHIEF EXECUTIVE: Patrick Stewart
MODEL: Marketplace
DESCRIPTION: Formed by Weirton Steel, LTV and Steel Dynamics, the site
serves as a sealed-bid auction-style exchange, online catalog and information
aggregator. It logs more than 5,200 transactions a month, charging between .25%
and 2% for each. Offers carbon steel and some stainless steel. Monthly
inventory: 150,000 tons.
CLIENTS: Bethlehem Steel, LTV, Weirton Steel.
BUZZ: Internet Capital Group bought a 35% stake from Weirton Steel for
$180 million. In March MetalSite teamed with Metal Management and Philip
Services to launch ScrapSite.Net, an exchange for steel and nonferrous scrap
metal.
Metal Suppliers Online
(Private)
www.metalsuppliersonline.com
CHIEF EXECUTIVE: Alan Gamble
MODEL: Marketplace
DESCRIPTION: Generates 90% of revenues by charging a $500 yearly fee for
its database of mill service-center and extrusion-shop inventories. Offers specs
on nearly 17,000 steel and nonferrous grades. Builds Web sites for mills and
metal centers and makes money from banner ads. Charges 2% to 5% for
transactions.
CLIENTS: Timken, Admiral Metals, RTI International Metals
BUZZ: Gamble raised $1 million from angel investors and moved the
operation from his bedroom to a 5,000-square-foot office north of Boston.
Onlinemetals.com
(Private)
www.onlinemetals.com
CHIEF EXECUTIVE: John Byrum
MODEL: Marketplace
DESCRIPTION: Targets orders too small for traditional service-centers
which move material in large sheets and demands a $250 to $500 minimum order.
Average order size: $100; average savings online: 50%. Carries a slew of sizes
in inventory and many grades of steel
CLIENTS: NASA, Kodak and machine shops.
BUZZ: Number of orders has grown more than 500% in one year. Teamed with
Machinetool.com, a portal for that industry, to increase traffic.n